Brazil Supreme Court Prepares To Revisit Gambling Prohibition
Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF) has taken a step towards reconsidering the country’s gambling prohibition after Justice Flávio Dino returned a case he had suspended for review in August. The proceedings examine whether gambling should remain a criminal misdemeanor under Brazilian law.
Dino returned the case on Thursday, November 12. The STF has yet to set a date for the next hearing. That decision rests with court president Justice Edson Fachin.
The dispute centres on Article 50 of the 1941 Misdemeanor Act. It prohibits gambling and prescribes simple imprisonment of three months to one year, together with a fine. Judges must consider whether the restriction remains consistent with Brazil’s 1988 Constitution.
Judges Weigh Combined Hearings On Gambling Disputes
Dino requested additional time in August, as the court considered whether several legal challenges involving gambling and betting should be heard together. The related proceedings concern municipal lotteries and other activities in Brazil’s betting market.
Justice Luiz Fux, the rapporteur handling the challenge to the gambling prohibition, voted to retain the existing punishment. He also accepted the possibility of bringing related lawsuits into a joint hearing after a 90-day period, allowing time to prepare a broader opinion.
Justice Dias Toffoli backed a combined examination, pointing to changes in the gambling industry since the original legislation came into force.
“It is not just about the Misdemeanor Act. It is a new, complex, and difficult world; it is not the world of the 1940s,” he declared.
Fachin initially favoured separate judgments but said he would consider the other justices’ arguments. During the November 4 discussion of ADPF 1212, he indicated that a coordinated approach could follow arguments presented at a recent public hearing.
“The Presidency’s stance is toward a separate judgment,” Fachin stated during the session discussing ADPF 1212. “However, I am open, of course, to the considerations of the panel and, given what we have seen here, including some arguments referencing yesterday’s public hearing, perhaps that is the path to eventually follow.”
Municipal Lottery Authority Adds Another Legal Challenge
The prospect of grouping the cases gained attention during the STF’s November 4 session. Justices heard arguments in ADPF 1212, which concerns whether municipalities can establish and operate their own lottery services, including sports lotteries.
The discussion followed a public hearing on the effects of a provisional measure signed by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on September 25. That measure suspended the operation, offering and advertising of sports betting and online games throughout Brazil. Its legality is also being challenged before the STF.
Provisional Measure Extended Into 2027
The National Congress has yet to establish the joint committee responsible for examining the measure. Meanwhile, Senate President Davi Alcolumbre extended its validity by another 60 days.
Taking into account the suspension of legislative deadlines during the parliamentary recess, the extension could keep the measure in force until March 2027.
A combined hearing would allow the STF to consider connected questions surrounding gambling restrictions, betting activities and municipal lottery powers. The court has not confirmed whether it will adopt that approach or when the suspended case will return to its agenda.







