Playtech Shares Fluctuate as Evolution Settles Defamation Case
Evolution has reached a settlement with litigation firm Calcagni & Kanefsky LLP (C&K) in its defamation dispute over a 2021 report alleging the live casino supplier operated in restricted jurisdictions. The agreement was disclosed on 17 November as proceedings began in New Jersey, leaving private intelligence firm Black Cube as the remaining defendant.
Playtech shares fell as much as 10% before recovering shortly ahead of the hearing. The movement prompted speculation that investors may have reacted to information surrounding the settlement, although no confirmed explanation for the fluctuation emerged.
The dispute centres on allegations that Evolution games were accessible in US-sanctioned countries and other prohibited markets. The report triggered substantial losses in Evolution’s market value, prompting legal action against those involved in its publication.
Settlement Leaves Black Cube Facing Legal Challenge
Evolution’s lawsuit initially involved C&K, which had represented the report’s allegations, and Black Cube, subsequently identified as the intelligence agency behind the document. Court proceedings eventually revealed Playtech as the commissioning party.
Evolution has sought to bring Playtech into the litigation as a defendant. However, the court ruled that the company could not be added until proceedings under New Jersey’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA) had concluded.
At the start of the hearing, C&K’s lawyers informed the court that their client had settled with Evolution. Black Cube consequently remains the sole defendant in the current proceedings, which were originally scheduled to begin a day earlier.
Black Cube’s legal team requested access to the settlement agreement, arguing that its terms and timing could affect the case. C&K’s counsel declined to disclose the document without a court order, citing confidentiality obligations. Judge John Porto indicated that additional submissions might be necessary, potentially extending the process by around 30 days.
Dispute Over Evidence And Legal Protections
Black Cube’s lawyers characterised the settlement as a “white flag of surrender” and said they understood that the agreement contained no financial component. The terms have not been publicly confirmed.
The hearing also raised questions about UPEPA’s constitutionality. Judge Porto noted that his research had identified relatively few rulings addressing the legislation across the United States.
Black Cube argued that its report relied on truthful information and should receive protection under the law. Its lawyers pointed to previously disclosed evidence, including attempts to access Evolution games in the disputed jurisdictions and recordings of conversations with company employees and business partners.
The defence also highlighted C&K’s involvement in reviewing the report’s material, arguing that the firm had devoted considerable time to checking the allegations. Evolution has previously challenged the reliability of this evidence.
Spectrum Investigation Adds Another Dimension
Black Cube recently secured disclosure of Evolution’s internal Spectrum Gaming investigation. The intelligence firm contends that the findings support the allegations contained in its report, while Evolution has maintained that Spectrum could not substantiate many of the claims.
The outcome of the UPEPA proceedings could determine whether Evolution can proceed with adding Playtech to the litigation. If the court rules in Evolution’s favour, the parties could enter discovery before a subsequent trial involving the additional defendant.







